The Idea of Hegel's "Science of Logic"

By Stanley Rosen

Although Hegel considered Science of Logic essential to his philosophy, it has bought scant observation in comparison with the opposite 3 books he released in his lifetime. right here thinker Stanley Rosen rescues the Science of Logic from obscurity, arguing that its forget is answerable for modern philosophy’s fracture into many alternative and adversarial faculties of notion. via deep and cautious research, Rosen sheds new mild at the designated difficulties that animate Hegel’s missed ebook and their great value to philosophical conceptions of good judgment and reason.

Rosen’s overarching query is how, if in any respect, rationalism can conquer the break up among monism and dualism. Monism—which claims a novel essence for all things—ultimately ends up in nihilism, whereas dualism, which claims a number of, irreducible essences, results in what Rosen calls “the never-ending chatter of the heritage of philosophy.” The Science of Logic, he argues, is the basic textual content to supply a brand new perception of rationalism that may conquer this philosophical cut up. prime readers via Hegel’s ebook from commencing to finish, Rosen’s argument culminates in a masterful bankruptcy at the proposal in Hegel. through absolutely appreciating theScience of Logic and situating it appropriately inside of Hegel’s oeuvre, Rosen in flip presents new instruments for wrangling with the conceptual puzzles that experience introduced such a lot of different philosophers to disaster.

Show description

Quick preview of The Idea of Hegel's "Science of Logic" PDF

Similar Philosophy books

The Twilight of the Idols and the Anti-Christ: or How to Philosophize with a Hammer (Penguin Classics)

'One needs to be more advantageous to mankind in strength, in loftiness of soul—in contempt’In those devastating works, Nietzsche bargains a sustained and sometimes vitriolic assault at the morality and the ideals of his time, specifically these of Hegel, Kant and Schopenhaur. Twilight of the Idols is a ‘grand assertion of warfare’ on cause, psychology and theology that mixes hugely charged own assaults on his contemporaries with a lightning travel of his personal philosophy.

Think: A Compelling Introduction to Philosophy

Right here eventually is a coherent, unintimidating advent to the hard and engaging panorama of Western philosophy. Written expressly for "anyone who believes there are enormous questions available in the market, yet doesn't know the way toapproach them," imagine offers a legitimate framework for exploring the main easy issues of philosophy, and for knowing how significant philosophers have tackled the questions that experience pressed themselves such a lot forcefully on human attention.

Moody Minds Distempered: Essays on Melancholy and Depression

In Moody Minds Distempered thinker Jennifer Radden assembles numerous many years of her study on depression and melancholy. The chapters are ordered into 3 different types: these approximately highbrow and clinical historical past of depression and melancholy; those who emphasize points of the ethical, mental and scientific good points of those thoughts; and eventually, those who discover the sorrowful and worried temper states lengthy linked to depression and depressive subjectivity.

Thought and Reality (Lines of Thought)

During this brief, lucid, wealthy publication Michael Dummett units out his perspectives approximately the various private questions in philosophy. the elemental query of metaphysics is: what does fact include? to reply to this, Dummett holds, it is crucial to claim what types of truth receive, and what constitutes their keeping sturdy.

Additional resources for The Idea of Hegel's "Science of Logic"

Show sample text content

Five In an age that has been no longer in basic terms ruled yet saturated by way of the mathematical and experimental sciences, speak about wisdom of the complete needs to appear terribly imprecise or even pretentious. To this objection, there are numerous responses. the 1st is to copy the former statement that wisdom of the “whole” isn't really for Hegel a alternative for the person sciences. In phrases that light up Hegel’s Kantian background, it's the account of the stipulations for the lifestyles and intelligibility of something whatever. 6 As such, it's the theoretical counterpart to what Aristotle intended through phronesis, which, he says, is worried with the entire of existence, that's, with how each one functional act contributes to the perfection of existence as a complete and never simply to the given context of task. yet, additionally like phronesis, a theoretical account of the entire is a “science” in its personal correct, in which I suggest that it addresses itself to a specific material, specifically, the set of the main common houses of expertise. This technological know-how has its personal tools and its personal technical terminology. And the issues it stories are direct results of the actual sciences or nonetheless extra essentially, of the character of discursive pondering. Very faraway from being an unscientific philosopher, Hegel suffers from the other ailment. The Hegelian procedure, and particularly the SL, is solely ruled by way of the clinical target of whole rationalization. Hegel will argue in exhaustive element that if whatever whatever is intelligible, then every thing is. This thesis itself relies on an intensive revision of the Kantian doctrine that nature conforms to the workings of the human intelligence, to which has to be extra the corollary that this paintings is itself intelligible or that it could actually no longer happen other than as intelligible to the employee. The Kantian claims to understand the overall (transcendental) constitution of rational paintings, that is the cognitive creation of the realm of expertise and technological know-how. This in flip offers us with wisdom of the “phenomenal” international, that's to claim, the area that looks to us because the direct results of our personal effective task. however it leaves in overall darkness no matter what lies past or outdoor the horizon of perceptual and conceptual cognition. Hegel takes the next move through purporting to illustrate that not anything lies past the horizon of conceptual pondering, and that “nothing” is itself the identify of an idea, and so of a constituent of the method in which issues come into lifestyles and cross away. to place this hard aspect in a wholly introductory approach, Hegel’s logical revolution rests upon the conceptual mastery of not anything, or his demonstration that it's the related as being, or a piece extra totally, that being and not anything are the 2 facets of turning into. If this sounds imprecise, we've basically to consider the way sleek common sense and set conception outline “not” or negation as a syntactical operator or suggestion. Propositions inside a given language are precise or fake based upon whether or not they safely show what's or isn't the case.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.94 of 5 – based on 7 votes